I agree with Nabokov, a good reader has to treat a novel like they would a piece of art. As readers we must perceive the world of the author without comparing it to our own when we are first acquainting ourselves with the new surroundings as this can taint our perception of the world that was created for us. Before, I had thought to be a good reader, one simply had to apply themselves to the novel. Take the big details and pass over the small. I was wrong with this philosophy. I believe Nabokov when he says a good reader needs imagination, memory, a dictionary and artistic sense. I love to read, but realized after reviewing Vladimir Nabokov’s “Good Readers and Good Writers” that I am a bad reader. When I read, I try to find common ground, somewhere where I can relate to the author. I also love books that impose nostalgia upon me, so that I can reflect on myself within the book. After reading Nabokov’s piece, I am intent on changing the way I read so I can submerse myself into new worlds, unbiased and with a slight sense of disconnect from my own reality. I am grateful to have been enlightened by Nabokov, if I had not I may have never fully understood what it means to be a good reader.
As I said in my introduction video, my favorite culture is Japan. I practice various martial arts and always try to aspire to have the mental and physical discipline of the mighty Samurai's I have grown up admiring. In Japan, the fiercest of all warriors were the Samurais. Its surprising that they took education very seriously, especially literature. They valued literature as much as they valued martial arts, because if they were good fighters but were ignorant they could not govern if the chance presented itself. Interesting, even the mighty Samurai knew the importance of being a good reader and writer. I apologize that I am going to submit a wiki link as for the moment I can't find any links with a brief explanation of the Samurai and their value on education and literature comprehension. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samurai
-David Hubbard
Works Cited
Trade Show Samurai. np., n.d.Web. 21 Jan. 2012 < http://www.tradeshowsamurai.com/Nabokov, Vladimir. "Good Readers and Good Writers." Norton Reader: An Anthology of Nonfiction.
11th Edition (nd): 613-17. Print.
Hi David, thanks again for such an inspired comment to my blog post. You really got me thinking. I really like your writting style, it is personal, yet informative and knowledgeable. As you know, I tended to disagree with Nabokov's overall statement that a reader must stay aloof and unattached, however, through reading your blog post I begin to see just what Nabokov was suggesting. Through your blog post, I gather that by staying unattached and unbiased when reading I might be able to gain more understanding of the author's world and in turn become more immersed into the book, not less. I also appreciate the way you were able to relate something you love (the culture of Japan) to this assignment to add even more insight into the topic. Thanks again! I look forward to having this class with you.
ReplyDeleteAh, David-san. You enjoy Tokugawa Japan? The haiku, the kabuki, the tea ceremony,...lovely artistic elements of the era. Check out the works of Basho for a true grasp of the literary talents of the age. Here's a sample of Basho's work, his last before his death:
ReplyDeleteOn a journey, ill
and my dream o'er withered fields
are wandering still.
I'm certainly glad you recognized a common failing of all of us when we read, namely our preconceived notions and prejudices. I mentioned the same thing in my blog. These internal issues can get in the way of truly understanding what we are reading, but it isn't an easy thing to identify nor to limit.
I'll leave you with a Gene Hackman line from the old movie Superman:
"Some people can read War & Peace, and come away thinking it was only a story. Others can read the ingredients of chewing gum, and unlock the secrets of the universe."
Pretty true stuff.
James Carr
Hey David,
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed your post on Nabokov's "Good Readers and Good Writers". Your writing style is easily read and your points were great. I had never looked at reading as a work of art I just merely read the text and then was done with it. After reading Nabokov's document I will use his advice to become an invested reader, I'm excited to have a new outlook and tools to read with. Have a great semester! I look forward to reading your posts in the future.
This is in my opinion the most complete definition of Nabokov's ideas. I agree that if I had also not read this piece I would perhaps have never been informed that I have a lot to work on as a reader. I have always known that reading was extremely important but I did not consider it like that of an art. I am anxious to now try to read in this manner even starting with the current book I am reading. Authors present a world of information that they have thought up or actually experienced for themselves. By learning how to read their ideas adequately, readers can in some ways experience everything the author has. The information on the Samurai Warrior is very interesting as well!
ReplyDeleteHey David,
ReplyDeleteYou are great at reorganizing your own thoughts about a piece. I also agree that writing is an art. I am going to strive to get my points across as elegantly as you. Thank you for the info on the Japanese Samurais. I think when you love a subject you can breed interest. I look forward to your posts.